The Honey Boo Boo Trainwreck: She's No Shirley Temple
After local folks from our Facebook community weighed in on the "Here Comes Honey Boo Boo" show, Hazelwood Patch wants to know how you feel about the stars and their lifestyle.
"You better red-neck-onize!"
Whether you love the show or despise it, the fact is that TLC's Here Comes Honey Boo Boo is a ratings success. In fact, Perez Hilton reports, the show recently received the highest ratings of its record-breaking season—nearly 3 million people tuned in to watch.
“Here Comes Honey Boo Boo has become a pop culture phenomenon,” one show rep told Hilton. “What you see is what you get and we are excited to share even more of Alana and her family's unbridled hilarity, sincerity and love with our viewers.”
Train-Wreck Allure?
We wondered whether people were watching the show for its “unbridled hilarity, sincerity and love,” so we asked our Facebook community what they thought about Honey Boo Boo and her family—and they didn’t hold back.
Like Hazelwood Patch on Facebook and join our discussions in real time!
“I think it's a horrible show that glorifies the worst kind of behavior and lifestyle by turning it into a comedy,” posted Jim Threadgill. “The fact that it’s popular at all is just sad. By far one of the worst things on ‘television.’”
Threadgill added that the appeal of the show is its “train-wreck factor,” noting that he is pretty sure that’s why his wife watches it.
“I can’t stomach it,” he said. “Also sadly, it reminds me of a lot of people that I grew up with in southern Missouri. I’m so glad I moved to the city!”
“That Family Needs Help”
Kelly Kirkbride said she refuses to watch the show because she couldn’t stand “Honey Boo Boo,” whose real name is Alana, when she watched her on Toddlers and Tiaras in previous seasons.
“From what I have seen of commercials and news clips, that family needs help,” Kirkbride said.
Chris Carboneau had just one thing to add: “Is it real though?”
Is This a Case for CPS?
Threadgill and others mentioned that some of the antics on the show could be used as evidence against the family if child protective services were called in to investigate, but he added that the producers of the show probably highlight the “worst things about the family.”
Most agreed that the show is probably engineered to “highlight the crazy,” like many reality TV shows, but that at last the family seems to have a lot of love for one another, even if they are physically unhealthy.
Pulling No Punches
Some of our Facebook friends were even bolder in their statements about the Honey Boo Boo show.
Kelly Pollard Wadlow weighed in, noting that she couldn’t stand the show or the family.
“And I’m sorry, but not the little girl either. There is no reason in the world that people need to raise their children to think it’s ok and normal to act like such Hoosiers,” Wadlow said. “And if they are (which we all know they are) pulling out the worst stuff for the show, the fact that they act like that to make it the worst stuff is awful.”
Wadlow added that the fact that the family speaks so unclearly that the show often requires subtitles is “awful.”
“Yes, I realize they are from the south and they have a stronger accent, but it’s still bad,” she posted.
“Surely if you wanted to watch a bunch of fat hicks you could just go to a trailer park and watch it in 4D rather than in HD or 3D,” posted Cal Black. “It goes to show that you can literally put any garbage on TV and people will watch it.”
She’s No Shirley Temple
Nance Rosen said that while Honey Boo Boo is “no Shirley Temple,” she’s not sure that exploiting a child for mass entertainment is the right thing to do in any era.
“The Olsen twins say they really regret their childhood years,” Rosen posted. “And if their billion dollar fortune doesn’t assuage the loss of those years, the minor amount of money Honey Boo Boo is ‘earning’ probably won’t sit well with her later on.”
Add your voice to the conversation! What do you think about the Here Comes Honey Boo Boo show? Share your thoughts in the comments section, below!
Loretta Logan-Snyder
12:54 pm on Friday, September 28, 2012
The show is an entertaining train wreck, but I am concerned with the bad eating habits and lack of values it promotes. The favoritism is very apparent and I don't know if it is bad or just lazy parenting that allows this little diva to get away with murder.
Angela Atkinson
12:56 pm on Friday, September 28, 2012
Haha, "entertaining train wreck." I like that. I totally agree on the bad eating habits--they're dooming this child to a life of obesity, IMO. There does seem to be favoritism from the parents with the kids too. Sad.
Joe SubKinetix Cuevas
1:04 pm on Friday, September 28, 2012
seems kinda... pointless..?
Angela Atkinson
1:06 pm on Friday, September 28, 2012
I hear you, Joe. I've heard the same from many people--but the fact remains that the show is insanely popular. So I have to wonder, what do people see in it? :) I think it's the trainwreck factor, I really do.
Cal Black
1:19 pm on Friday, September 28, 2012
I don't watch this show and never will, it's the sort of thing that makes me throw up in my own mouth. Whatever they are being paid per episode is too much...if someone paid me to come film me messing around at home I can guarantee it would be a lot funnier and more educational than this trash.
Angela Atkinson
1:22 pm on Friday, September 28, 2012
Haha, understood Cal, and thanks for joining the conversation on Facebook too!
Jim Threadgill
4:23 pm on Friday, September 28, 2012
I feel the need to clarify that I didn't mean that child services should get ivolved just because they are kind of simple folks. Hell that's pretty close to how I came up in Sikeston! I just don't care for the way that they gloirfy the "redneck" behavior. Then again that has been going on for years with the likes of Jeff Foxworthy, Larry the Cable Guy etc.
Angela Atkinson
7:40 pm on Friday, September 28, 2012
Definitely, Jim, and for the record, I didn't get that feeling from you at all. And I agree with you on the redneck glorification--except I don't think it's "redneck" so much as what we St. Louis-area people call "hoosier." I often see good country people who embrace the "redneck" thing as sort of a positive thing. While it's not my personal preference, I guess maybe it could be likened to any other geographically/culturally-connected group.
On a similar note, I found myself giggling when I watched the DNC and heard the folks from Indiana proudly using the term hoosier to refer to themselves, saying things such as "Hoosiers deserve good healthcare and hoosiers deserve great jobs,etc." That's because I'm from around here--a lot of Indianans are offended when I tell them what hoosier means in St. Louis. :)
Loretta Parker
4:23 pm on Friday, September 28, 2012
To Jim,some people from southeast Missouri aren't the red necks you are glad to get away from but very nice people. As to the horrible accents that need subtitles,have you listened to some of the residents from Florissant? Some grade school teachers need to have a translator to understand the name of the child.
Angela Atkinson
7:42 pm on Friday, September 28, 2012
You make some good points, Loretta. Thanks for jumping in and sharing your thoughts! :)
Jim Threadgill
7:29 pm on Friday, September 28, 2012
I wasn't saying everyone down there is bad, like I said I grew up there. But there are many more opportunities here than there is in a small town like Sikeston. There are bad stereotypes no matter where you go, more at some places than others. My point was that this show highlights the worst behavior and glorifies it by making it a comedy. It just saddens me that these people are being laughed at by the whole country for their embarrassing behavior. I apologize if I offended you. I really wasn't calling everyone out there a redneck.
Angela Atkinson
7:46 pm on Friday, September 28, 2012
Jim, like I mentioned in response to your earlier post, I definitely didn't get that feeling from you! You always add really smart and thought-provoking ideas and opinions to our discussions and I truly appreciate it. I've seen nothing but tolerance and open-mindedness from you. Thanks too for sharing your thoughts here and responding to Ms. Loretta! :)
Lazy people suck
11:26 am on Monday, October 1, 2012
So June the welfare momma has her own show interesting .That girl is no Shirley for sure Shirley was a cute talented well mannered little girl not a fat and ugly slob.Shirley has good parents not ones with criminal history.
Angela Atkinson
11:30 am on Monday, October 1, 2012
Seems like your opinion is right in line with the majority! Thank you for sharing your thoughts. :)